Selling Diamond Jewelry: A Practical Guide
Diamonds are valued differently than gold or silver — there's no single "spot price." Here's a plain-English look at what actually goes into a diamond's value.
What are the 4 Cs?
Cut, color, clarity and carat weight are the four standard factors used to describe a diamond. Cut affects how the stone reflects light, color measures how colorless the stone is, clarity refers to internal or surface characteristics, and carat weight is simply the stone's size. Together, they give a consistent way to describe and compare diamonds.
Do I need a certificate to sell my diamond?
No, but a grading certificate (such as from the GIA) can support a stronger, faster evaluation if you have one. If you don't, that's completely fine — we can evaluate the stone directly using professional tools.
Does the setting matter?
Yes, in two ways. First, the setting's precious metal (gold, platinum, etc.) has its own separate value, which is added to the offer. Second, an original setting can sometimes support a stronger overall evaluation, though it's not required — loose diamonds are evaluated just as readily as set ones.
What affects a diamond's resale value the most?
Market demand plays a bigger role in resale value than many people expect — diamonds are generally purchased at retail with a significant markup, and resale reflects wholesale market value rather than the original retail price. A free evaluation is the most reliable way to understand what a specific stone is actually worth today.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you buy loose diamonds?
Yes, loose stones and diamonds set in jewelry are both evaluated.
Will my offer match what I paid at retail?
Typically not — resale value reflects current market demand rather than original retail price, which includes a significant markup.
Do you buy diamond earrings and bracelets, not just rings?
Yes — all diamond jewelry types are evaluated.
Have a diamond ring, earrings, or loose stones to evaluate?
Get My Free Quote